Current Reviews


Scooby Doo #104

Posted: Saturday, January 14, 2006
By: Ray Tate

"The Ice-Manster Cometh"
"Total Washout"
"Bite-Sized Beasties"

Writer: Various
Artists: Various
Publisher: DC

The Manster was a two-headed Japanese monster just slightly pre-dating the giant monster genre that would become associated with Toei productions. Thus, Alex Simmons story begins with a double joke: the play of words involving of course The Ice Man Cometh and the more subtle joke of including a nod to a Japanese classic.

Japan doesn't figure into Mr. Simmons story. Instead, we have a haunted ice cream factory, and a very intriguing design for our fake monster--or manster, if you prefer--by the accomplished Joe Staton and enhanced by sharp inker Horacioi Ottolini. This is indeed very keeping with the formula of Scooby-Doo in that the monsters never looked fake. We knew that they would be unmasked as say "Creepy Uncle Joe!" but the monsters never looked fake. Heroic Age must also be given credit for the cold colors that give off the ghostly glow.

Simmons' story is a treat. It departs cleverly from the formula of fairplay and instead diverts into a detective story that while perplexing stays slickly paced with a rational explanation for the behavior of the culprit.

The third story by Simmons possesses a very easy to solve mystery, but the setup injects some new life into the usual eerie backdrops, and the execution of the crime relies on elegant contraptions that offer fun for Mystery Inc. to discover.

Robert Pope and Scott McCrae with Heroic Age provide a plethora of pretty props to entice the readers’ eyes. The characters are many and never do they blend together, and the esoterica of the mystery solving is well staged.

The second mystery "Total Wash Out" by Frank Strom doesn't live up to its name, but it's not exactly memorable. This is a shame because Karen Matchette loads the story with a number of visually interesting characters.

What did you think of this book?
Have your say at the Line of Fire Forum!