Current Reviews


Doom Patrol #2

Posted: Friday, July 30, 2004
By: Shawn Hill

“Hearts of Darkness”

Writer/Artist: John Byrne
Inker: Doug Hazlewood

Publisher: DC

Less talky, more active (though quite why we need to see Rita fall through the same wall for the third or fourth time in three issues is unclear; it’s not THAT great a composition; are all future issues going to hinge on that moment as well?), as the Tenth Circle storyline finally wraps up in a neat, tidy, totally formulaic package.

Not gonna say a lot about this one, except that it’s much better than the first issue. We get a flashback to Larry Traynor’s origin, which makes it pretty clear that Byrne has a thing for Hal Jordan. Still, it’s well-handled, if a bit hokey.

We also get more team interaction, with focal moments for Faith, Nudge and Grunt. The battle with the uninteresting Vampire-possessed meta-humans is prolonged and disappointing. If “Rubber Maid” is meant to be an updated Madame Rogue, she’s a total misfire. Stealing the powers without the personality is not the way to go. Meltzer does better in one panel of Identity Crisis with his perved-up Phobia, who seems updated but remains recognizable.

There’s a by-the-numbers set-up of the next plot, as roughly inserted as all of the plot directions in this story, and a highly predictable denouement that for some reason takes even Batman by surprise involving the worst character Byrne ever created (a creepy dimensional warper/MacGuffin, too annoying to merely be mediocre).

Of interest:
While I praised a similar cover on Byrne’s JLA arc (where all the heroes are surrounded in tight full-figure formation by their foes), it doesn’t work as well here with less-iconic characters. Some of that might be remedied next issue when these “newcomers” get costumes. A lot rests on how Byrne handles Cliff Steele, too, because he’s usually the focal point for these outings. That might change with Rita alive again, though, as she does show a lot of welcome attitude and spunk, especially on the final page when she criticizes the Chief.

What did you think of this book?
Have your say at the Line of Fire Forum!